Sunday, 21 February 2016

Sam Delawarr: An SMBI Community Campaigner's View of Redland City Council


My name is Sam Delawarr and I have been a ratepayer in Redlands for 35 years.
 

I'm a retired Senior Nurse and, until a some eight years ago, I happily paid my rates and  had little to do with local politics, other than attending various community meetings.  I had also provided written input into some regional and local planning issues for the South Moreton Bay Island (SMBI) community.

I was the  President of the Moreton Bay Combined Islands Association for many of the years of Council administrations past and have been tracking the issues relating to the SMBIs for decades.


The Southern Moreton Bay Islands comprise Macleay, Karragara, Lamb and Russell Islands.
The four islands are part of the Statistical Local Area of Redland Bay (Balance) and part of Division 5



















I am sharing my views with Redlands Life so that those who may not otherwise pay attention, might understand the types of issues that are of concern to the most far flung of this City' residents - its SMBI residents.

I became more closely involved with local issues when the Redland City Council delivered a 205% hike in rates.  I became concerned about the:
  • Withdrawal of infrastructure;
  • Dismissal of residents’ concerns;
  • Vast accumulating debt;
  • Council staffing numbers that seemed to be increasing disproportionately;  
  • Extent of the fees being paid by the then Council to external consultants without a decision ever resulting; and 
  • Hijacking of our water supply by the State Government.

I am not a developer, real estate agent, LNP supporter nor political donor, nor do I have any ties with this current Council other than a genuine appreciation for the turn around  that has come about under its watch.

I am simply someone who has been paying attention as a campaigner on behalf of the rights of people living on the SMBIs.

I was by turns disgusted, alarmed and horrified by what went on during the previous Council Administration.

In 2010 the then Hobson Administration commissioned a $440,000 report on 'Redland Rate Model Engagement' which included a 'Community Survey on Ratings Values 2010', with some involvement in the process by now Mayoral Candidate Greg Underwood.

After securing these documents under the Right To Information - despite much of what I had asked for having "disappeared" -  I discovered that community concerns were being manipulated by either the bureaucracy, staff and/or councillors.

I found that 80% of Redland ratepayers were demanding infrastructure to be spread across the whole of the City and not just in suburbs that were already over-serviced and appeared to do very well, year after year, with  disproportionate revenue allocations. 

The largest suburb in the Redlands in terms of both population (ratepayers) and revenue raising, that is the SMBIs, was receiving little to no funds for  infrastructure. 

The vast majority of Redlanders, the survey found, believed the rating system was unfair, with high-end land  rates values subsidized by the low end properties which were paying an unfair level of Council rates.

But these views were ignored by the Administration in which Mr Underwood played a central role.  (In fact he was Acting CEO at the time). 

Massive rates increases occurred across the City from 2008-2011,  some of which were and remain the highest rates per land value in Australia - unfortunately where rates are concerned, they can never go backwards. 

What I discovered was that those in charge of Redland City Council at the time had misrepresented the findings of the survey to read '22% agree to rates exploitation of lowered value properties'.   

This misleading and inaccurate 'fact' was used to set some really devastating property rates that saw ratepayers on the SMBIs lose their land, lifestyle and retirements and created a property crash unheard of in Australia previously.

All of this devastation and injustice occurred while the past Council (Melva's Mob)  ruled with a big stick approach to ratepayers.

It was an attitude that caused such angst in our close SMBI community that Melva was pushed out in a landslide.

I am, as you can imagine, distressed by the idea that the same Administration is seeking another go with some of the same faces in place.

Under the previous regime, what was once was my beautiful retirement dream, like so many others, became our worst nightmare.

Through my role with the MBCI Association for many of those last dreadful Melva years,  I heard many stories from mum and dad ratepayers that were absolutely heartbreaking.  I was watching a he complete breakdown  of morale in our SMBI communities.

To add insult to injury, a deal was later struck between the Council and the State in land grabs and to withhold all infrastructure.

As I saw it, this was  just another example of the Council’s systemised attack on its southern suburbs of Redlands, while  the northern suburbs did very well  with infrastructure, amenities and services.  

We on the islands have for 40 years paid our rates, that went into general revenue, and received very little in return other than to say your rates are 'paying off council debt'.

You can understand then why I am a great supporter of the current Administration, led by Karen Williams.

As the largest revenue and ratepayer base in Redlands, the SMBIs have seen Council's nett debt returned to zero.  

We have seen infrastructure spread out over all suburbs and a sense that progress and justice has returned to Redlands.

The fear campaigns promoting the threat of 'concrete jungles' by those who came here and live in their developed homes on the various-sized  lots need to get some perspective.  

Only a small amount of  housing has been designated as small lots and with just over 9,700 Redlands people living alone according to the last Census, there are some who prefer smaller properties.  These are usually located along transport and infrastructure routes like it is in all Local Government Aareas across the South East. 

believe our children, our families and those of every Redlands ratepayer need somewhere to live and that needs to happen now for the ongoing implementation of new infrastructure to be delivered to the City.

I was involved with the urban renewal designs for New Farm /Teneriffe over 38 years  ago  (via QUT) and the need for all types of housing availability was the big story then, just as it is today.  

That particular project transformed an urban wasteland into a community, supplying all types of housing  needs to a very healthy and prosperous suburb including parks, a mosaic overlay of house and accommodations types, employment opportunities and lifestyle.

I am so appreciative of the work done by the Williams team over the past four years.   

To to see a sense of community and progress come back to the SMBIs has been wonderful. 

To have a rational and decisive Council to follow through has been refreshing.  Yes, I still have issues that do not sit well but at least you can discuss them rationally and are heard  by most Councillors.  This was certainly not the case before.

I also appreciate the fact that that my rates do not go to pay off huge wasteful debts!

I especially want to thank Karen Williams, who was the main Redlands push to get rid of that huge wasteful blunder that was Allconnex.  We pay the cheapest water in South East and if not for her, Disconexx and the Gold Coast City Council, we would still be paying a fortune in water rates. 

For those that are new to the area, there are some very organised and schmik community pages/ supposed news sites  designed and run by the old regime trying to create drama and fear.

Please do some homework on these so called "community pages".


If they only promote those aligned with the old Council and never publish any of the good that has come Redlands way over the past four years, then treat them with a pinch of salt like I do.

We never had it so good in Redlands as we have in the last four years and I hope it continues way into the future.

My report card gives Williams an A.

  

7 comments:

  1. What Sam Delawarr fails to mention which would have an enormous bearing on the content of this article is that ( Melvas Mob ), as she puts it was also the first council to substantially increase SMBI infrastructure spending to over $4million dollars in her first full year as Mayor then around $3.5 million each year following as a direct result of her increase in rate revenue. Melvas total spend on SMBI infrastructure during her council term was $11.1 Million. This Mayor Williams led council have reduced this spending by almost two thirds as is reported in the Council Annual reports from 2008 until present, the total spend as reported in her financial report totals $4.1 million, but still charges the same rates. Please gather all the facts before you are swayed by one persons limited report from a biased perspective and place your vote where it will do the most good for SMBI and the Redlands. Comment by Peter Hanson, Birkdale

    ReplyDelete
  2. thanks Peter/ Melva for you debate , can you give me a list of those projects that the 205% rates increases paid for ???? which equated to approx $15million in the first year increasing steadily yearly up to $18 million???? I would and so would the rest of the SMBI like to see those projects you state as $11.5 spend over the same period that saw a minimum of $60 million collected by the then council ....

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sam Delawarr, the information I provided on SMBI infrastructure spending is taken from the government requirement to publish council Annual Reports found and freely available when accessed on the web. I am not a spokesman for this or any other council just reading the publicaly available information to compare this council spending compared to the last two. If you want to research every single project and costing this money was spent on I am sure it is also very easily researched but as you do not even avail yourself of the information i provided I am not about to waste my time on your poorly researched article. I know from memory many roads on Macleay Island were sealed under a properly constructed road programme by the Hobson led council along with the purchase of Jock Kennedy farm,car parking upgrades,land purchase for open space and environmental protection on SMBI. This is just a few I can recall.

    ReplyDelete
  5. yes there were a couple of roads on Macleay that were sealed and one in particular comes to mind ...surrounded by dirt roads but not in front of this house ...I will have to get that houses address from someone living on Macleay though I think I might have photos ....You might know who lived there at the time ????

    ReplyDelete
  6. minutes dated 17 June 2008, Responsible officer Acting CEO Greg Underwood …FM corporate Budget …….councillors determined that funds raised for 2008/2009 budget should be increased by 100% for the SMBI only …..moved cr Bowler seconded Cr Reimers ……..the remaining budget included Raby Bay, Aquatic Paradise and Sovereign Waters rises of between 7 %and 13% on just their levies growth noted at 0.8%plus rates rises across the city of the average 5.2% land fill and tip fees up 6.7% and water charges up 30% …so Peter Hanson …there are the facts ,not nit picked but straight from the start of that dreadful era and they increased dramatically over that 4 year period until Smbi was 205% higher and the canal estates also being targeted . But then along came the Williams team and in July 2012 FM coeporate budget responsible officer Martin drysdale presented By Cr Talty that a 30% cap will be applied to categories identified as 3a-3b ,4a-4b and 12a-12b of the SMBI ratings categories …(.That’s your land as well Peter Hanson)The same applied to those being financial abused on the canal estates as well ….all increases were kept to the CPI across the city …. moved Cr Beard seconded Cr M Edwards overall report had 2 that did not want those community savings and a new era of sustainable council attitudes…those against Crs Ogilvie and Elliot ….so Peter before you try to discredit people that have those genuine facts maybe the information being feed to yáll might be nit picked or filtered to try and glorify ,the memory of Financial bullying and arrogant control over the city of Redlands that we all suffered .

    ReplyDelete